Lightroom versus Capture One 3rd edition
I see photo editing as a natural thing to do. Editing isn’t really what I intend to do. I would rather adjust. We don’t edit to invent; we edit to translate. At the end, I put a link to the full article and video.
The camera records what the sensor could see; we try to show what we feel.
What I remind myself when I sit down to edit
- Exposure is a negotiation. Raise shadows to show what my eyes are adapted to—or let them fall if the weight of the scene lives in the contrast.
- Direct the eye. Local dodging/burning and gentle colour shaping aren’t “effects”; they’re composition after the fact—guiding attention to the moment inside the frame.
- Stay honest. I’m fine with cropping, straightening, balancing tone and colour, and removing sensor dust. I avoid removing real‑world elements. If it was there, it stays—because the small imperfections are often the story.
- Make sequences live together. Editing or adjustments isn’t just about singles; it’s consistency across a project—white balance, contrast, and colour relation so the set reads as one voice.
- Output matters. Print wants different mid‑tones than a phone. Edit for where the picture will live.
For me, the craft is to get as close as possible in camera, then use the editor as a quiet instrument: controlled, minimal, and with the same respect for the moment as when I pressed the shutter.
If you want the tools side of it: a 2026 snapshot
Capture One (16.6–16.7 + March 2026)
- Better masking/retouching (Combine Masks, Retouch Eyes/Teeth, Clothes Masking; plus mask thumbnails and PSD/PSB alpha-channel export for clean hand‑offs to Photoshop).
- Session Builder + sensible on‑set flow for pre‑built folder structures and natural, slider‑based facial retouching that carries forward while tethering.
- Faster exports and AI masking speed‑ups (notably on Apple silicon).
- Film negative conversion built‑in—batch‑consistent, no plug‑ins.
Lightroom Classic (v15.x, Oct 2025 → Feb 2026)
- Assisted Culling + Auto Stack for faster selects, plus Auto Dust Removal in the Remove tool.
- Improved object/shadow/reflection detection in masking.
- PSB pipeline + steady cloud/mobile polish across the Lightroom ecosystem for people who want everything synced.
Where I am in 2026
My pick for my files and way of working is Capture One. Lightroom remains the better choice if you rely on Adobe’s cloud and AI‑assisted culling. I changed this in my own workflow, and you can read about that in the article and watch the video attached to the article below.
Read the full comparison
I’ve put the full side‑by‑side here and included a video.
Capture One vs Lightroom – Which One Brings Out the Best in Your Files?
Share this:
Discover more from Morten Albek Photography
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
