My reality is the opposite. In both Lightroom Classic and Capture One, I rarely use the Contrast slider. Not because it’s “bad”, but because I want to decide—separately—three things that the word contrast tends to blur together:

1. Where the image becomes truly black (black point)
2. How deep the shadow detail sits (shadow midtones)
3. How much separation I want between tones (global or midtone contrast)

Lightroom and Capture One can both do all of this brilliantly. The difference is how each program expects you to think about it—and which tools feel like “home” when you’re shaping blacks and shadows.

If you want to know even more and get experts’ tips and guidance, dive into a workshop where we also edit. Check the workshop and book your space. 

Why I Skip The Contrast Slider

“Contrast” is a broad instruction: increase the separation between light and dark. Adobe even defines it in that broad, global way: increasing contrast darkens darker areas and lightens lighter areas.

That’s exactly why I avoid it.

Most of the time, I don’t want to increase separation everywhere equally. I want to:

• Set a deliberate black point (sometimes rich, sometimes lifted)
• Decide how much shadow detail stays visible
• Shape the lower midtones without crushing texture

Lightroom actually encourages this way of thinking by clearly separating the tonal roles: “Shadows” are dark areas with detail, while “Blacks” are completely dark areas without detail, and the Blacks slider defines how the darkest tones map to pure black (the black point).

That mental model—shadow detail vs black point—is the core of my workflow.

Lightroom Classic: Black Point and Shadow Depth

In Lightroom, I can build my contrast “from the bottom up” without ever touching Contrast, because the panel gives me direct levers for the two things I care about most:

1. BLACKS = WHERE TRUE BLACK LIVES Lightroom’s own guidance is explicit: the Blacks slider defines how the darkest tones map to pure black (the black point). Moving it left darkens that point, adding richness; moving it right lifts it for a more refined/matte feel.

So Blacks are not “shadow mood.” It’s the foundation—the anchor.

1. SHADOWS = WHERE DETAIL IN THE DARKS LIVES
   Shadows, in Lightroom’s terminology, are dark tones that still carry information. The Shadows slider is designed to recover detail in darker areas.

This is why Lightroom feels so fast for the way I work: I can place the black point, then place the shadow detail, and the image immediately starts to feel intentional.

1. CURVES (OPTIONAL) = SHAPE THE FEEL OF THE LOWER MIDTONES
   If I need more “bend” than the sliders give me, Lightroom’s own teaching points to the classic S-curve approach for increasing contrast by lowering darker tones and raising brighter tones.

But even then, I’m still thinking in the same order: anchor blacks, shape shadows, then fine-tune the roll-off.

My Lightroom contrast workflow (without using Contrast)

• Set Exposure to a sensible baseline
• Pull Blacks down (or lift them) to place the black point
• Adjust Shadows to decide how much dark detail is visible
• If needed: use a gentle curve to shape lower-mid separation rather than “global punch”

Capture One: The Same Goal, But A Different Home Base

In Capture One, I’m still doing the same job—black point, shadow detail, tonal separation—but the program’s “natural” tools for that job live elsewhere.

If Lightroom makes you feel like you’re sculpting tonality with sliders, Capture One often expects you to establish the foundation with Levels and Curves.

All of this is something we look deeper into and train on the 3 days workshops, including workflow and feedback.
Check the workshop and book your space. 

1. LEVELS = BASE CONTRAST AND TONAL RANGE (INCLUDING BLACK POINT)
   Capture One’s documentation describes the Levels tool as mapping tonal values and expanding the tonal range shown in the Levels histogram—especially useful in low-contrast scenes. It also explains that Auto Levels attempts to set the shadow and highlight sliders to either side of the histogram, increasing contrast and altering brightness.

This is important: in Capture One, Levels is where “base contrast” and black/white anchoring naturally begin.
It’s the equivalent of what I’m doing with Blacks (and sometimes Whites) in Lightroom—except it’s expressed as endpoints and range mapping.

1. CURVES = AFTER LEVELS, FOR FINER CONTROL (ESPECIALLY SHADOW MIDTONES).
   Capture One is very direct about sequencing: after adjustments in Levels, the Curve tool is used to further adjust contrast and colour balance, and it offers greater flexibility and control of shadow midtones and highlights.

This is basically Capture One saying: “Set your boundaries first, then sculpt.”

1. RGB VS LUMA CURVE = CONTRAST WITH OR WITHOUT EXTRA SATURATION.
   Capture One also acknowledges a practical side effect: increasing contrast with an RGB curve typically increases saturation, which may be fine for landscapes but not always desirable for portraits—so use Luma mode when you want contrast without boosting saturation.

That’s a big deal if your “contrast” is really a tonal decision and you don’t want skin to get louder just because shadows got deeper.

What About The Contrast Slider In Capture One?

Even though I don’t use it, it’s worth understanding why it feels different from Lightroom’s.

A clear explanation from Thomas Fitzgerald’s breakdown is that Capture One’s Contrast slider appears to use an S-curve-like method that adds contrast without significantly affecting black and white points; the histogram ends appear anchored in place.

That design choice makes sense—but it also explains the experience many Lightroom users have: if you expect “contrast” to also dig the blacks deeper, Capture One’s Contrast can feel polite. Because it’s not primarily a black-point tool. Levels are.

My Capture One contrast workflow (without using Contrast)

• Exposure to baseline
• Levels to place black point (and white point if needed) and establish base range
• Curves to shape the shadow midtones and overall separation after Levels
• Luma curve when I want contrast without the saturation side effect

Same Intent, Different Language

This is the real takeaway:

In Lightroom, the “language” of the edit is tonal regions:

• Shadows = dark detail
• Blacks = black point (true black)

In Capture One, the “language” is tonal mapping and sculpting:

• Levels = expand/position tonal range (including shadow/highlight endpoints)
• Curves = refine contrast and shadow-mid control after Levels

So if you’re like me—someone who wants to adjust blacks and shadows separately—the workflow isn’t “harder” in Capture One. It just starts in a different place.

A SIMPLE TRANSLATION CHEAT-SHEET (WITHOUT THE CONTRAST SLIDER)

Lightroom Classic

• Black point: Blacks slider sets the black point and adds richness when darkened
• Shadow depth/detail: Shadows slider recovers or deepens dark detail
• Shape: Curves for targeted tonal sculpting (S-curve approach)

Capture One

• Black point/base contrast: Levels expand tonal range and positions shadow/highlight points
• Shadow-mid shaping: Curves after Levels for greater control of shadow midtones and highlights
• Keep colour stable: Luma curve avoids the saturation increase typical of RGB curve contrast changes

CLOSING: CONTROL FEELS SLOW UNTIL IT FEELS LIKE YOURS

The reason I avoid the Contrast slider is the same reason I love both programs: I want the image to arrive through decisions, not through a single broad push.

Lightroom makes those decisions feel immediate because Blacks and Shadows are laid out like a tonal map. Capture One makes them feel deliberate because Levels and Curves ask you to build the foundation first, then shape it.

Same destination. Different roads.

READ MORE ABOUT MORTEN ALBEK WORKSHOPS HERE